Maintaining international contacts is
challenging, to say the least. While
schooling is a huge priority for me, I need to remember that responding to my
questions is not top on my contact’s list of things to do. Sapna (from India) is the only one of my three contacts who
responded, and I feel as if we are becoming fast friends. I find her extremely up-to-date on what is
developmentally appropriate (although she feels her hands are tied), and I
think her creativity is amazing; for the new school year, they are using only
home-made toys, and she offered to send me this adorable dog that she created
with yarn.
Her ending comments to me expressed how
difficult it was for her to respond to my questions. She admits to being blunt, only because she
is aware that I need the truth. However,
Sapna claims that it hurts her to share what is happening, because in her
words, “it’s a very sorry state of affairs.”
While Sapna never described the word quality,
it was almost as if there was not such a definition; it was on the back
burner. In her society, it is more
important to for all children to get an education… then quality might factor
in. The ministry has state bodies who
look into the quality of early childhood education, but the job is not followed
through. A specific uniform curriculum
does not exist. There are different
types of schools which house young children, such as state schools, central
board schools, private schools, and international schools (most expensive). I do not quite understand the differences…
however, for families who cannot afford to send their children to school, there
are municipality and village schools, as well as schools run by non-government
organizations. The quality of teachers
in this last school grouping is, as Sapna stated “not always good.”
The teachers need to pass a simple “bed”
exam (similar to a diploma exam), and there is basically no follow-up with the
teachers once they are hired. When I
questioned Sapna about this, she reminded me that most of the parents are
uneducated, so they do not know any difference.
In addition, teachers and parents in the non-government schools have no
knowledge as to what the schools should be teaching.
In rural village India, there are no
preschools or kindergartens. Children
start school in the first grade. In
semi-urban or small cities, there are a very few preschool kindergartens (one
class with both names). However, Sapna
repeated again that “there is absolutely no curriculum or understanding of
curriculum.”
Obviously, these words hurt Sapna, because
she knows differently. She is lucky
enough to be working in a private school… but I would agree with her words, “it
is a sorry state of affairs.”
Lois,
ReplyDeleteYour post is staggeringly sad to know that children in India are not receiving quality education. It is even sadder to think that parents are so uneducated that they do not know the difference. There needs to be some criteria or standards that should be met within schools in order to ensure education is top quality. At minimum teacher qualifications would help aid in delivering quality education. Has your international contact shared any information about what India is doing to change quality in schools?
Hi Erika! From what I gathered from Sapna, I do not believe that India is doing much... perhaps, they aren't aware, as a country, of the importance of quality education or they do not how to go about bringing this to frutation. I could hear the sadness and disappointment in Sapna's words. Thanks for commenting and sharing your thoughts, Erika.
DeleteI find your post heart-breaking to say the least. It is sad to hear that early childhood education is undervalued so. It sounds like there is an issue of quantity over quality. Sapna's school is lucky to have a teacher such as her, that is so dedicated. It would be challenging to work in a field that is so undervalued! Hopefully as other countries focus on the sciences that support the importance of early childhood programs of high quality, more advocates will step forward in her country.
ReplyDeleteHi Lois, I think it is probably a shock for you to know the situation in India, but for me, I kind of understand that. In China, some parts of the country are like that too. Children and their familiar are still struggling to get educated, let alone the quality. Accessibility to school is many families' first concern here. India has the second largest population in the world, and poverty is one of the most serious issues in that country. I understand if the population cannot have their daily needs to be met, they cannot think anything beyond that.
ReplyDelete